4 Most Popular Sources of Protein
Which source of protein is actually the best? What are protein products? What is the difference between whey, casein, soy and egg white?
Protein
Proteins are high-molecular-weight natural substances with a relative molecular mass of 103 to 106, made up of amino acids. Proteins are the basis of all living organisms. In proteins, amino acids are linked to one another by amino groups –NH2 and carboxyl groups –COOH through so-called amide bonds –NH–CO– (amides), also known as peptide bonds. Depending on the number of amino acids linked together in this way in a molecule, we distinguish between oligopeptides (2–10 amino acids), polypeptides (11–100) and proteins (more than 100 amino acids).
Production is based on natural sources of protein
Of course, these products also contain a wide range of carbohydrates, but very little sucrose (cane sugar). There is an inverse relationship between the carbohydrate and protein content of these concentrates. Fat content is kept to a minimum and consists mostly of unsaturated fatty acids, which are generally beneficial to health. These are not synthetic preparations; their production is based on natural sources of protein. Leaving aside some plant-based sources such as wheat protein (once you’ve tried it, you’ll never want it again), 4 natural sources of protein are essentially used to make them:
- whey
- casein
- soy
- egg white
Which of these sources is actually the best? Most of you will surely answer whey, which is the raw material used to make whey protein products. But hold on: in its head-to-head contest with the other three contenders, it does not necessarily come out on top in every respect. Each has its strengths as well as its drawbacks. Let’s take a closer look at all these sources.
Whey is the favorite
Whey is first dried, and a whey protein product is then obtained from the dried product using complex production processes, usually ultrafiltration. Here I’d like to point out a very common misconception: confusing dried whey with WPC. So, let’s clarify the key differences. On average, dried whey contains 69% milk sugar (lactose) and just 15% protein. WPC, on the other hand, has roughly the opposite proportions, averaging at least 65% protein and 11% carbohydrates (milk sugar—lactose). As a result, people who think they’ve bought a protein concentrate at a very reasonable price are often mistaken. At best, they’ve bought a low-quality gainer that may simply cause digestive problems. WPC production costs 4 to 5 times more than dried whey.
What are the advantages of WPC?
- very good and rapid digestibility – WPC is known as a “fast” protein. Amino acid levels rise very quickly after consumption (aminoacidemia), so the amino acids needed reach their destination as soon as possible
- the highest bioavailability of protein – this means that our digestive system can make use of a large proportion of the protein we consume
- the best amino acid profile thanks to its high content of branched-chain amino acids (BCAAs) – these play a unique role in protein metabolism and contribute to the composition of muscle protein.
- excellent taste
- protein is generally associated with the growth and maintenance of muscle mass
Does WPC have any drawbacks?
Basically just one: it has no anticatabolic effects, meaning it does not slow the breakdown of muscle mass and cannot supply muscles with the amino acids they need for several hours.
Next in line... casein
Casein is essentially the protein found in cottage cheese. It is something of a “sibling” to whey protein, since both are made from the same source—milk. But you’d be hard-pressed to find two “siblings” with such different properties!
Before 1989, bodybuilders at every level of competition had eaten so much cottage cheese that they developed an aversion to this source of protein. What’s more, casein was considered a low-quality source of protein for many years. That has all changed now. A groundbreaking French study from 1997 demonstrated the benefits of casein as the best source of protein for protecting muscle mass against catabolism.
It has completely opposite properties to whey protein, as it suppresses muscle breakdown more effectively than any other protein, particularly during the “fasting” period overnight. It is digested and absorbed very slowly, ensuring a steady supply of amino acids to the muscles. This means that the two sources complement each other perfectly. To maintain high amino acid levels for muscle recovery for 5 to 7 hours and achieve an anticatabolic effect, choose a protein containing casein. Casein is also known as a “slow” protein.
Soy
Soy was long considered an “outsider” among the protein sources mentioned, but unfairly so. Its benefits have only been fully appreciated in recent years, which is also reflected in its inclusion in a range of protein products.
The raw ingredient itself—soybeans—contains an impressive 40% high-quality protein with a broad amino acid profile, rich in arginine (a recent hit as a nitric oxide producer) and glutamine. Soy is notable for its isoflavone content (plant estrogens).
Egg white
Egg white has long been a mainstay among protein sources, and its popularity has never waned. Particularly for those looking for an inexpensive source of protein, dried egg white—with almost 80% protein—is unbeatable, but the taste... Its amino acid profile is balanced, but nothing about it stands out. Its digestion and absorption rate is relatively slow, putting it in second place after casein and placing it among the “slow” proteins. It is therefore a suitable ingredient in slow-release protein products.
Summary
It’s important to know which source your protein comes from. Protein products are quite easy to classify, making it easier to find your way around the huge range of products available. But what’s even more important for users? Knowing how to use this classification to choose the right protein for a truly effective workout. A less-than-ideal choice may not help you achieve your goal as effectively as it could, and it may also cause digestive discomfort both during and after your workout.